Theft & Property Crime Lawyers in Fishers, Indiana

If you have been arrested or charged with theft or another property crime, your next steps can significantly affect your future. A misdemeanor theft conviction can affect your job prospects, housing options, and professional licenses. Felony offenses carry more severe penalties. Because theft is viewed as a crime of dishonesty, employers and landlords often judge it more harshly than other offenses. 

At Merchant Law LLC, our theft and property crime lawyers have experience defending individuals accused of shoplifting, burglary, receiving stolen property, criminal mischief, and other related crimes. Our goal is to help you protect your rights, challenge the prosecution’s evidence, and pursue the outcome you want for your case. 

Located in Fishers, Indiana, we serve clients throughout Hamilton County, Boone County, Hancock County, and Marion County. We will listen to your side of the story, explain the charges you face, and help you build a strong defense strategy. Contact us to schedule a consultation. 

Understanding Theft and Property Crime Charges in Indiana

Under Indiana Code § 35-43-4-2, a person can be charged with theft when they knowingly or intentionally exert unauthorized control over another person’s property with the intent to deprive the owner of any part of its value or use. The severity of the charge will depend largely on the value of the property and your criminal history: 

  • Class A misdemeanor: Applies to the theft of property valued at less than $750 and is punishable by up to one year in jail and a fine of up to $5,000. 

  • Level 6 felony: Applies to the theft of property valued between $750 and $50,000, theft of a motor vehicle or vehicle part, or theft by someone with a prior unrelated conviction for theft, conversion, robbery, or burglary. Potential consequences for a Level 6 felony include six months to two and a half years' jail time and a fine of up to $10,000. 

  • Level 5 felony: Applies to the theft of property valued at $50,000 or more, the theft of a firearm, and certain other aggravating circumstances. Potential consequences for a Level 5 felony include one to six years’ jail time and a fine of up to $10,000. 

Indiana also has strict sentencing and penalties for related property crimes, including burglary, robbery, criminal conversion, fraud, criminal mischief, and criminal trespass. Penalties can increase sharply if the court finds aggravating circumstances, such as the accused entering a dwelling, using a weapon, or injuring someone. A conviction for these types of crimes often includes court-ordered restitution. 

If you have been charged with theft or a related property crime, consult our experienced Indiana criminal defense attorneys for tailored representation and guidance on how to defend against your charges. 

Facing a Criminal Charge?

Contact Us

Our Theft & Property Crime Defense Services

At Merchant Law LLC, we provide dedicated representation for various theft and property crimes, from the initial investigation through trial and, if necessary, appeal. Our primary theft and property crime defense services include: 

  • Shoplifting and retail theft: We can help you defend against allegations based on store surveillance footage, loss prevention reports, or employee statements. We also advise those who receive civil demand letters from retailers. 

  • Burglary and robbery: We defend against serious felony charges involving unlawful entry into a building or taking property by force or threat. 

  • Receiving stolen property: We represent clients accused of knowingly or intentionally exerting unauthorized control over property belonging to another person.

  • Criminal conversion: We help defend against charges involving knowingly or intentionally exerting unauthorized control over another person's property.

  • Auto theft: We help clients defend against accusations involving motor vehicles or vehicle parts, including allegations of joyriding. 

  • Fraud and embezzlement: We represent clients in property crimes committed through deception, false statements, or abuse of a position of trust. 

  • Criminal mischief and vandalism: We can help you defend against allegations of damaging or defacing another person’s property. 

  • Criminal trespass: We help clients defend against charges for entering, trespassing, and remaining on property without permission. 

Regardless of the charge you face, we will strive to negotiate with prosecutors wherever possible to reduce charges and pursue pretrial diversion programs, which can often help first-time offenders avoid a conviction. When appropriate, we may be able to seek alternative misdemeanor sentencing to convert a Level 6 felony to a misdemeanor. 

How Our Firm Can Help

At Merchant Law LLC, our attorneys, Edward J. Merchant and Martin A. Brown, bring extensive courtroom experience to every case, and prosecutors know we are prepared to take a case to trial when they don't offer a fair resolution. 

We can help you examine surveillance video, receipts, and witness statements for inconsistencies and challenge the claimed property value, which can be the difference between a misdemeanor and a felony. We can also investigate whether the police conducted lawful searches and whether statements were obtained in violation of your rights. 

Our attorneys will work directly with you, explain each development of your case in plain language, and give honest, practical advice so you can make informed decisions about your defense. We know a criminal charge can affect more than your court case, so we tailor our defense strategies to help you protect what matters most. 

Contact Our Theft and Property Crime Lawyers in Fishers, Indiana

A theft or property crime charge can threaten your freedom, your finances, and your reputation, but an accusation is not a conviction. At Merchant Law LLC, we defend clients facing a wide range of criminal charges, from misdemeanor shoplifting and felony burglary to robbery. We will investigate the evidence against you, challenge weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, and pursue reduced charges and diversion programs whenever possible. 

If you have been charged with a theft or property crime, contact us to schedule a consultation and discuss your defense options. Located in Fishers, Indiana, we serve clients throughout Boone County, Hamilton County, Hancock County, and Marion County.